Is trading halal? Stocks, margin and short selling
There is no single answer for everyone: rulings are a matter for scholars. Most consider buying shares of a company with permissible business and moderate debt acceptable. Most consider trading on borrowed money (margin), short selling and interest-bearing products impermissible.
Many Islamic funds and indices rely on AAOIFI Standard No. 21. Under it the company's core business must be permissible (not alcohol, gambling, pork, interest-based banking or insurance), interest-bearing debt must be under 30% of market value, interest-bearing deposits and securities also under 30%, and income from impermissible activity under 5% of revenue.
If a small part of the company's income still comes from impermissible activity, the matching share of the profit is given away as charity (sadaqah). This is called purification.
Most consider buying a stock with your own money acceptable, and swing trading too if the shares are fully paid. Views on day trading differ. Margin involves an interest-bearing loan from the broker, short selling means selling what you do not own, and many classify options and futures as gharar, excessive uncertainty.
| Method | Majority view | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Buying a stock with your own money | permissible | ownership of a stake in the company |
| Swing trading (days to weeks) | most allow it | the shares are fully paid |
| Day trading | disputed | selling before settlement completes |
| Margin (trading on credit) | impermissible | an interest-bearing loan from the broker |
| Short selling | impermissible | selling what you do not own |
| Options and futures | most do not allow them | gharar, excessive uncertainty |
FAQ
Is buying an ETF halal?
An ordinary index fund holds banks and heavily indebted companies too. For those who follow Sharia there are separate Islamic funds screened by these criteria.
Are dividends halal?
Most consider dividends from a company with permissible business acceptable; the share attributable to impermissible income is purified.
Read next
Ratings, the screener and signals are in the terminal.
Open the terminal